Atelier API "Ondes gravitationnelles et objets compacts"

→ Europe/Paris
Bâtiment Perrault - Salle du conseil (Observatoire de Paris - site de Paris)

Bâtiment Perrault - Salle du conseil

Observatoire de Paris - site de Paris

Observatoire de Paris 77 avenue Denfert-Rochereau 75014 Paris
Description

L'atelier annuel de l'action incitative "ondes gravitationnelles et objets compacts" aura lieu du 23 au 25 novembre 2026 dans la salle du conseil du bâtiment Perrault à Paris.


L'atelier sera organisée autour de présentations de codes communautaires et de contributions orales plus "classiques." Parmi les présentations invitées, il y aura:

  • Susanna Barsanti (University College Dubin) : 
  • Eric Gourgoulhon (LUX) : hands-on session sur SageMath
  • Nils Vu (University of Zurich) : SpECTRE: Numerical Relativity with discontinuous Galerkin methods
Bureau de l'API
    • Contributed talks
      • 1
        Welcoming and API info
      • 2
        The LISA Global-Fit problem

        The spatial gravitational waves observatory LISA has been officially adopted by ESA in January 2024 and its launch is currently planned for 2035, leaving a decade to face all the data analysis challenges posed by the expected data. In this presentation I will present the various sources of LISA with their associated science cases and how this leads to new challenges in gravitational data analysis. The current approach, the so-called global-fit, and its associated costs, will be presented. I will finally briefly focus on time-frequency approaches that are foreseen as a promising tool to enhance computational speed and save computation resources in the analysis.

        Orateur: Gaël Servignat (APC)
      • 3
        Integrability of spinning and eccentric binary black holes

        Averaged over the orbit, the second post-Newtonian spin dynamics of binary black holes is an integrable Hamiltonian system, for any eccentricity. We construct its action-angle variables explicitly from the flows generated by its conserved quantities. This gives the precession and nutation frequencies in closed form. We then propose a criterion that locates where this description breaks down. Applied to spinning binaries, it identifies the up-down instability and extends its threshold to eccentric orbits.

        Orateur: Tom Colin (LUX)
    • Coffee break
    • Review talk
      • 4
        EMRIs waveforms beyond GR
        Orateur: Susanna Barsanti (University College Dublin)
    • Lunch break
    • Contributed talks
      • 5
        Detectability of the spin parameters of SgrA* using multiple S stars

        The orbits of S stars around the Galactic Center black hole, Sgr~A, offer a unique opportunity to probe the relativistic regime of gravity and test the no-hair theorem. While the Schwarzschild precession has been detected with S2, the detection of spin-induced (Kerr) effects—Lense–Thirring and quadrupole moment terms—remains a major observational challenge. We aim to quantify the time needed to detect the spin parameters of Sgr~A—magnitude and orientation—by exploiting astrometric and spectroscopic monitoring of multiple S stars with current (GRAVITY+, ERIS) and future facilities (MICADO). Using the post-Newtonian integrator, we simulate long-term astrometric observations of individual and combined S-star systems, including S2, S29, S38 and S55, and the recently discovered S301. We quantify spin detectability through $\chi^2$ minimization and forecast the evolution of spin-parameter uncertainties over the coming decades. We show that S301 has spin sensitivity comparable to a star identical to S2 but ten-times closer to Sgr A, and that combining its data with those of other stars of diverse orientations (S2, S29, S38, S55) reduces parameter degeneracies and accelerates spin detection. Quantitative forecasts indicate that the spin magnitude can be constrained to $\sigma_\chi \simeq$ 0.1 by 2032, 0.05 by 2034, and 0.03 by 2036 when only fitting the spin magnitude $\chi$, with comparable results when fitting all spin parameters. Astrometry provides the dominant leverage, while spectroscopy adds substantial value only if radial-velocity precision reaches ~2 km/s, as expected with MICADO. Overall, spin detectability is robust given sufficient monitoring and knowledge of orbital parameters. The black hole orientation is a critical factor, along with multi-star, multi-instrument datasets, which together offer the most promising path forward. The joint monitoring of multiple S stars with GRAVITY+ and MICADO will enable robust measurement of the spin of Sgr~A within the next decade. Astrometry remains indispensable for achieving this goal, while high-precision spectroscopy will serve as a critical complement once the required velocity accuracy is reached.

        Orateur: Karim Abd El Dayem (Observatoire de Paris (LIRA))
    • hands-on session: SageManifold: SageManifold
    • Coffee break
    • hands-on session: SageManifold: SageManifold
    • Contributed talks
      • 6
        From Signal to Noise in Pulsar Timing Arrays

        Pulsar timing arrays (PTAs)  aim to detect nanohertz gravitational waves, and their sensitivity depends on modeling noise due to propagation effects caused by Ionised Interstellar medium (IISM). In this talk, we present our ongoing efforts. We will first brief results from our project on search for bursts with linear gravitational-wave memory (LGWM) from close hyperbolic encounters of supermassive black holes. These events induce ramp-like signatures in timing residuals. Using an efficient post-Newtonian prescription for hyperbolic orbits, we present initial results from the MeerKAT Pulsar Timing Array 4.5-year data release of 83 millisecond pulsars. Our Bayesian framework models pulsar-specific intrinsic noise alongside the burst signal. Secondly, we will also introduce our Pulsar Interstellar scintiLLation And scatteR broadening Studies (PILLARS) project, a coordinated campaign studying scintillation and scatter broadening caused by the turbulent IISM. Quasi-simultaneous observations with NenuFAR, LOFAR, the GMRT, and the Nançay Radio Telescope span tens of MHz to 1.4 GHz, that will help in wideband study of the IISM. For a subset of pulsars, we report preliminary measurements of scintillation bandwidths, timescales, scattering times, and secondary-spectrum arc curvatures. We compare the resulting frequency-scaling indices with the Kolmogorov turbulence expectation. Together, these studies should help in strengthening scattering-noise modeling in PTA datasets and eventually help in gravitational-wave searches.

        Orateur: Prerna Rana (LPC2E, Orleans, France)
      • 7
        Pulsar Timing Arrays and low radio frequency data

        Pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) use the times of arrival (TOAs) of radio pulses from a set of millisecond pulsars, monitored over many years, to search for nanohertz gravitational waves. Their main target is the stochastic gravitational wave background (GWB), for which several PTAs reported evidence in 2023.
        Detecting and characterising the GWB requires an accurate model of the noise in the TOAs. One of the main contributions comes from the propagation of the radio signal through the ionised interstellar medium, parametrised by the dispersion measure (DM). DM variations introduce time-correlated delays that scale with the inverse square of the observing frequency and, if not properly modelled, can bias the GWB parameters. Simulations show that broad frequency coverage and long, densely sampled datasets are needed to constrain them (Ferranti et al. 2025, 2026; Zecca et al. 2026).
        We therefore combined the second data release of the European PTA with high-cadence observations from two European low-frequency telescopes, LOFAR (100–200 MHz, 13 years) and NenuFAR (below 100 MHz, 6 years). The low-frequency data improved the constraints on chromatic noise, reduced its covariance with achromatic processes, made many pulsars sensitive to higher-order chromatic effects, and showed limitations of current solar wind models. LOFAR and NenuFAR data are now included in the upcoming European and International PTA data releases, as they provide the lowest observing frequencies currently available to PTAs.

        Orateur: Francesco Iraci (APC, CNRS)
      • 8
        Rotating black hole solutions with a scalar hair

        New stationary and axisymmetric black hole solutions admitting a scalar hair will be presented. These solutions were found in a subset of Horndeski theories. The fully rotating solutions were obtained numerically using the Kadath library. They differ from Kerr in general, and depends on a new independant parameter.

        Orateur: Hugo Candan (LUX, Observatoire de Paris PSL & IJCLab, Université Paris-Saclay)
    • Coffee break
    • Review talk
      • 9
        SpECTRE: Numerical Relativity with discontinuous Galerkin methods

        I will give an introduction to the numerical relativity platform SpECTRE, which aims to simulate black hole mergers and gravitational waves for the next generation of gravitational wave detectors using high-order spectral (discontinuous Galerkin) methods and massive parallelism. I will introduce the code and the methods, and give examples how to use it.

        Orateur: Nils Vu (University of Zurich)
    • Lunch break
    • Contributed talks
      • 10
        Discussion on the future API
      • 11
        New Waveform Models for the Gravitational-Wave Memory Effect

        The nonlinear gravitational-wave (GW) memory effect produces a lasting offset in the GW strain following a burst of GWs from an isolated system. In this talk, I will present our recently developed phenomenological frequency-domain model for the dominant $(\ell,m)=(2,0)$ mode of the nonlinear memory signal from nonspinning, quasicircular binary-black-hole mergers. We construct separate phenomenological descriptions of the frequency-domain amplitude and phase using analytical fitting functions. The model is calibrated against the NRHybSur3dq8_CCE numerical-relativity surrogate over mass ratios $(1\leq q\leq 8)$, achieving mismatches of approximately $10^{-4}–10^{-3}$ across the mass range relevant to LIGO. I will discuss the model's construction, calibration, accuracy, and computational advantages, as well as its implementation in the open-source Python package GWMemoryModel. I will conclude with a preview of our ongoing efforts to extend these waveform models to spinning binaries.

        Orateur: Arwa Elhashash (LUX, Observatoire de Paris)
      • 12
        Black holes and neutron stars with scalar hair in Degenerate Higher-Order Scalar-Tensor (DHOST) theories

        We investigate black holes and neutron stars in Degenerate Higher-Order Scalar-Tensor (DHOST) theories of gravity. We study how the scalar field affects the structure and properties of compact objects, focusing on deviations from General Relativity in strong-field regimes. For neutron stars, we examine equilibrium configurations and mass–radius relations, while for black holes we explore the properties of their exterior spacetime and associated observables. Our results provide highlighted potential signatures that could be tested through electromagnetic and gravitational-wave observations.

        Orateur: Hamza Boumaza (Ecole Normale Supérieure-Kouba, B.P. 92, Vieux Kouba, 16050 Algiers, Algeria)
    • Coffee break
    • Contributed talks
      • 13
        Well-posed time evolution and field redefinition equivalence: From scalar fields to gravity

        I will review recent progress on how to systematically achieve classically well-posed time evolution in generic effective field theories, a prerequisite for obtaining systematic constraints from gravitational-wave observations of black-hole binaries. In particular, I will use an exemplary scalar Galileon theory to discuss the tension between perturbative field redefinitions and local well-posedness. I will show that the breakdown of field-redefinition equivalence coincides with a breakdown of the derivative expansion. Beyond this regime, one faces a choice between ill-posed time evolution and exciting the additional higher-derivative degrees of freedom. I will also comment on the relation of these results to screening mechanisms.

        Orateur: Aaron Held (École Normale Supérieure)
      • 14
        Converting gravitational memory to electromagnetic memory effects

        In this talk, we will discuss how the well known Gersenshtein effect allows a gravitational wave to generate indirect memory effects on the behavior of charged particles. In particular, we shall show that the conversion of gravitational radiation into electromagnetic radiation in the presence of a background electromagnetic field leaves specific cumulative imprints on key observables of the dynamics of charged particles. Focusing on linearized gravity, we will further show how the Killing-Yano symmetries of the Minkowski background allows one to build an exact solution for the indirect Gersenshtein effect and how this new solution elegantly organizes the transient and permanent response of charged particles to the incident gravitational wave. This provides an analytic description of new indirect memory effects through photon-graviton mixing, suggesting a new path to detect memory effects in the electromagnetic sector.

        Orateur: Jibril BEN ACHOUR (ENS de LYON)